You are here

Credible and Actionable Evidence

Credible and Actionable Evidence
The Foundation for Rigorous and Influential Evaluations

Second Edition
Edited by:

Other Titles in:
Evaluation | Evaluation (General)

November 2014 | 352 pages | SAGE Publications, Inc

Addressing one of the most important and contentious issues challenging applied research and evaluation practice today—what constitutes credible and actionable evidence?—this volume offers a balanced and current context in which to analyze the long-debated quantitative-qualitative paradigms. In the Second Edition, the contributors, a veritable “who’s who” in evaluation, discuss the diversity and changing nature of credible and actionable evidence; offer authoritative guidance about using credible and actionable evidence; explain how to use it to provide rigorous and influential evaluations; and include lessons from their own applied research and evaluation to suggest ways to address the key issues and challenges. Reflecting the latest developments in the field and covering both experimental and non-experimental methods, the new edition includes revised and updated chapters, summaries of strengths and weaknesses across varied approaches, and contains diverse definitions of evidence. Also included are two new chapters on assessing credibility and synthesizing evidence for policy makers. This is a valuable resource for students and others interested in how to best study and evaluate programs, policies, organizations, and other initiatives designed to improve aspects of the human condition and societal well-being.  

Melvin Mark
Credible Evidence: Changing the Terms of the Debate
Part I: Introduction
Michael Scriven
Demythologizing Causation & Evidence
Stewart I. Donaldson
1. Examining the Backbone of Contemporary Evaluation Practice: Credible and Actionable Evidence
George Julnes, Debra Rog
Evaluation Methods for Producing Actionable Evidence: Contextual Influences on Adequacy and Appropriateness of Method Choice
Christina A. Christie and Dreolin Fleischer
2. Social Inquiry Paradigms as a Frame for the Debate on Credible Evidence
Jennifer Greene
Evidence as 'Proof' and Evidence as 'Inkling'
Robin Lin Miller
3. How People Judge the Credibility of Information: Lessons for Evaluation From Cognitive and Information Sciences
Robin Miller
How people judge the credibility of information: Lessons for evaluation from cognitive and information sciences
Part II: Credible and Actionable Evidence: The Role of Randomized Experiments
Eleanor Chelimsky
Politics, Policy, and the Evaluation Synthesis
Gary T. Henry
4. When Getting It Right Matters: The Struggle for Rigorous Evidence of Impact and to Increase Its Influence Continues
Leonard Bickman, Stephanie Reich
Randomized Control Trials: A Gold Standard with Feet of Clay
Leonard Bickman and Stephanie M. Reich
5. Randomized Controlled Trials: A Gold Standard or Gold Plated?
Sharon Rallis
Reasoning Rigor and Probity: Ethical Premises for Credible Evidence
Michael Scriven
6. Demythologizing Causation and Evidence
Sandra Mathison
Seeing is Believing: The Credibility of Image Based Research and Evluation
Part III: Credible and Actionable Evidence: Perspectives From a Range of Evaluation Designs and Methods
Christina Christie, Dreolin Fleischer
Social Inquiry Paradigms as a Frame for the Debate on Credible Evidence
Sharon F. Rallis
7. When and How Qualitative Methods Provide Credible and Actionable Evidence: Reasoning With Rigor, Probity, and Transparency
Thomas Schwandt
Toward a Practical Theory of Evidence for Evaluation
Sandra Mathison
8. Seeing Is Believing: Using Images as Evidence in Evaluation
Gary Henry
When Getting it Right Matters: The Case for High Quality Policy and Program Impact Evaluations
Eleanor Chelimsky
9. Credibility, Policy Use, and the Evaluation Synthesis
Part IV: Credible and Actionable Evidence: General Perspectives
Jennifer C. Greene
10. How Evidence Earns Credibility in Evaluation
George Julnes and Debra Rog
11. Actionable Evidence in Context: Contextual Influences on Adequacy and Appropriateness of Method Choice in Evaluation
Thomas A. Schwandt
12. Credible Evidence of Effectiveness: Necessary but Not Sufficient
Melvin M. Mark
13. Credible and Actionable Evidence: A Framework, Overview, and Suggestions for Future Practice and Research

"Donaldson, Christie and Mark's thorough book on credible and actionable evidence provides a comprehensive overview of how thinking about this topic has evolved to its present state in the program evaluation community. There can never be a last word on the topic, but this is as good a current snapshot as one might find. I recommend it."

William R. Shadish, University of California, Merced

“The book is very well constructed in terms of building blocks to develop what the editors are addressing. The division into sections is a good example of strong organizational approach to a topic. The quality of the individual chapters is exemplary…[G]ood writing and solid expertise in compiling various aspects of the debate around research evaluation.” 

Audrey J. Penner, Holland College and University of Prince Edward Island

“A huge strength of the text is the discussion of research decisions within a social/cultural/political context. This is a critical conversation for students to have about applied research.”

Matthew J. Zagumny, Tennessee Technological University

"High quality papers on an important issue written by some of the top scholars in the field. A must read for those interested in the topic."

Ernie House
University of Colorado Boulder

Rigor generating credible evidence that influences decisions and action: that's the heady vision of an experimenting society. This book, bringing together evaluation's best thinkers and most astute practitioners, realistically explains why it's hard to achieve while inspirationally portraying how we can -- and sometimes do --get there.  A book for anyone interested in evaluations that make a difference.   

Michael Quinn Patton
Author of Utilization-Focused Evaluation

"'What is credible and actionable evidence?', and 'How can we provide it?' are challenging, but fundamental, issues in evaluation.  Experts across disciplines and perspectives have different views on the meaning and content of these concepts, and they often propose different strategies and methods for addressing these concerns.  Credible and Actionable Evidence makes an essential contribution to this discussion by providing a platform for experts to productively discuss these questions, in order to understand the nature of evidence and exploit possible solutions.  It is a great resource for anyone who is interested in enhancing the quality of evidence in their evaluation or applied research."

Huey T. Chen
Mercer University

Somewhat advanced for my undergraduate courses.

Humanities Fine Arts Dept, Front Range Community College
February 17, 2015

Sample Materials & Chapters

Chapter 1

Preview this book

For instructors

This book is not available as an inspection copy. For more information contact your local sales representative.

Purchasing options

Please select a format:

ISBN: 9781483306254

SAGE Knowledge is the ultimate social sciences digital library for students, researchers, and faculty. Hosting more than 4,400 titles, it includes an expansive range of SAGE eBook and eReference content, including scholarly monographs, reference works, handbooks, series, professional development titles, and more.

The platform allows researchers to cross-search and seamlessly access a wide breadth of must-have SAGE book and reference content from one source.

SAGE Knowledge brings together high-quality content from across our imprints, including CQ Press and Corwin titles.