Social-media messages in China censored, new research reveals
London, UK. In March 2015 a video documentary about air pollution in China, entitled ‘Under the Dome’, went viral. Yet, while it is well known that the video disappeared offline following government objection, what is lesser known is that hundreds of posts on Weibo, China’s equivalent to Twitter, were also censored for commenting on the film and its findings. In a new report from Index on Censorship magazine, published by SAGE, Professor Matthew Auer, from Bates College in the USA, and Associate Professor King-wa Fu, from the University of Hong Kong, reveal how they discovered and monitored the takedown of micro bloggers’ comments.
In the documentary Chai Jing, a former reporter for the state-owned broadcaster China Central Television, explains the lethal hazards of airborne soot in Chinese cities. The film, which was viewed more than 200 million times before it disappeared, included the tale of a six-year-old girl, who says she has never seen white clouds, stars, or blue skies.
The film initially gained praise from China’s environment minister, but official endorsements were quickly offset by stern warnings from the authorities to end all media coverage. As links to the video went dead and commentary was pulled down, international journalists were quick to report on the story, but no one was aware of how many Weibo commenters had been suppressed.
“What they missed was that hundreds of posters were censored on 1 and 2 March, days before the video started disappearing from popular video-sharing sites”, write the researchers in Index on Censorship. “Among the deleted messages we found condemnations of the state and photographs of anti-pollution demonstrations.”
Auer and Fu say some of the images taken down were of protesters with placards calling for the government to reduce the “haze” (air pollution):
“By the standards of Chinese censors, the messages conveyed by the protesters were not the problem. It is that they are demonstrating in the first place .[…] The panicky removal of the video from Chinese websites, followed by censorship of not only official commentary, but also the views of ordinary citizens, suggests that the state remains more effective at clamping down on public expression than on pollution.”
The full report includes examples of censored Weibo posts and an explanation of how they were tracked. The University of Hong Kong’s Weiboscope project monitors 350,000 popular Weibo accounts.
The issue also includes a separate report on the changing face of Chinese censorship, by Jemimah Steinfeld, with a case study on tricks used by The New York Times to get its content out in China, despite a ban on its website. And rising Chinese author Murong Xuecun speaks of his own battles to get his latest novel released and the cuts that were enforced.
# # #
“Clearing the air: investigating Weibo censorship in China, New research to show censorship of microbloggers who spoke out about pollution documentary” is published in Index on Censorship magazine, will be free to access for a limited time and can be read here.
About the authors: Matthew Auer is a professor of environmental studies and dean of the faculty at Bates College, USA, and King-wa Fu is an associate professor at the Journalism and Media Studies Centre of the University of Hong Kong.
The article is part of a special issue from Index on Censorship, addressing how yesterday’s and today’s censors compare. ‘Spies, secrets and lies’ takes a global approach and looks at the role new technologies play. It includes dispatches from South Korea, Argentina, India and South Africa. Find out more about the latest issue here.
The launch of the latest issue is taking place on October 13th at The Frontline Club in London. The panel debate is to be introduced by Stephen Grey, journalist and author of The New Spymasters, and Chaired by Rachael Jolley, editor of Index on Censorship magazine. Panelists include Robert McCrum, Xiaolu Guo, Ismail Einashe. Find out more about the launch event here.
# # #
SAGE Founded 50 years ago by Sara Miller McCune to support the dissemination of usable knowledge and educate a global community, SAGE publishes more than 850 journals and over 800 new books each year, spanning a wide range of subject areas. A growing selection of library products includes archives, data and video. SAGE remains majority owned by our founder and after her lifetime will become owned by a charitable trust that secures the company’s continued independence. Principal offices are located in Los Angeles, London, New Delhi, Singapore and Washington DC. www.sagepub.com
Index on Censorship – Launched in 1972, quarterly global magazine Index on Censorship has reporters around the world. International in outlook, outspoken in comment, and publishing some of the world’s finest writers, Index exposes stories that are suppressed, publishes banned writing, initiates debate and gives breadth to news that has often been “dumbed down” in the world’s media. Previous contributors include Margaret Atwood, Noam Chomsky, Nadine Gordimer, Aung San Suu Kyi, Salman Rushdie, Tom Stoppard and Ai Weiwei.www.indexoncensorship.org
Book review requests: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Access to journal articles: email@example.com
For inquiries regarding SAGE's corporate and public affairs contact: Louise Coady.